BigBear Is Stealing My Work

BigBear Is Stealing My Work

Yes, I am in my right mind.

Whenever I add an app to my AppStore, the first thing I do is check BigBear’s AppStore and Lintuxer’s AppStore. If the app isn’t available in either of them, I create my own. Sometimes, even if they already have it, I create my own version if their configuration or implementation is different.

However, over the past few days, I’ve noticed something strange: apps from my AppStore are also starting to appear in BigBear’s AppStore.

Now, I’m 100% sure something is going on. Why the hell would BigBear add Trackie, an Actual Budget fork specifically designed for New Zealand?

And it’s not just Trackie. I’m talking about apps like:

  • AutoXpose

  • BookOrbit

  • Claude Code

  • Cloudreve

  • Cloudreve Pro Fork

  • Continuwuity

  • Documenso

  • DocuSeal

  • Ente

  • Gamevault

  • Homedex

  • Homelable

  • OmniRoute

  • And many, many more.

What’s even more suspicious is that many of these apps have exactly the same variables as the ones in my AppStore.

Here’s another thing worth mentioning: most of the apps I add actually come from the r/selfhosted New Project Megathread. I check it every week, discover interesting new projects, and create apps for them so that people using ZimaOS and CasaOS can easily install and use them.

I spend my own time researching, configuring, testing, and maintaining these apps.

It’s genuinely disappointing, especially when IceWhale itself promotes the BigBear AppStore and even includes it pre-installed.

So, what’s the point of putting in all this effort if someone else can simply replicate my work?

Why the hell am I wasting my time doing this?

I’m done. No more.

That’s very bad news, your store had a massive potential and it was very well designed. Sorry to hear that mate.

I take my time adding every app and test every single feature. Apps like AppFlowy and Ente took me over 2 weeks because they’re super complex and rely on multiple services. I’d get one thing working, then something else would break. That’s how much time and effort went into making them work properly.

And then this guy just straight up copies my work. All that time and resources feel like they’ve gone to waste.

Yes, I use AI too but I don’t rely on it 100%. I test every single app, make manual changes, troubleshoot issues, and put in the actual work to make sure everything runs properly.

and I DON’T EVEN ASK FOR DONATIONS.

The saddest part? IceWhale themselves are promoting his work.

I want to respond to this because these are serious accusations against me and the work I’ve spent years building and maintaining.

First, I’m responding here as the developer of Big Bear, not in my capacity as a community moderator.

I’ve been developing Docker images, scripts, applications, and app stores for years. My work existed long before I started using AI, and much of it is publicly available in my GitHub repositories.

You’ve openly stated that you check Big Bear’s and Lintuxer’s app stores to discover applications, sometimes creating your own implementations. I have absolutely no problem with that. I’ve followed a similar discovery process for years.

When adding third-party applications, I consult upstream documentation and Docker Compose examples to create configurations for Big Bear. Similarities in standard images, ports, environment variables, and other settings are expected when deploying the same upstream software.

I also noticed that your own IceStore repository includes a publicly available Claude skill for creating and updating applications. That skill documents a workflow where an AI assistant researches upstream projects, gathers Docker images, environment variables, ports, and Compose configurations, and uses that information to generate application files.

Combined with your own description of discovering applications through other community stores, that represents a development workflow very similar to mine.

I don’t see anything wrong with that approach, whether the work is done manually or with AI assistance. However, I believe the same standards should apply to both of us.

Big Bear is also much more than a collection of third-party applications. I develop my own Docker images, scripts, and applications, including projects I’ve built entirely myself. I also maintain an independent infrastructure for supporting multiple platforms.

Examples of my work are publicly available:

I also continue to credit WisdomSky for the original app store template, despite how significantly Big Bear has evolved over the years. I’ve never had an issue recognizing someone’s actual contributions.

There’s a meaningful difference between acknowledging someone whose original work contributed to a project and discovering that a third-party application exists through another public catalog.

What I take issue with is being publicly accused of stealing someone’s work without specific evidence identifying what original material was copied.

I’ve addressed this in more detail in my GitHub response, including links to my repositories and an explanation of my development process.

If you believe specific original code, configurations, scripts, or other material was improperly copied, please identify the files and relevant sections. I’m willing to investigate legitimate concerns and address them appropriately.

I respect the work you’ve put into your app store and ask that you extend the same respect to mine. Accusations this serious should be based on verifiable evidence, not assumptions drawn from overlapping applications or shared upstream configurations.

As a moderator here, I believe it’s important that this discussion remain factual, respectful, and fair to everyone involved. Since I’m personally involved in this dispute, I’ll leave any moderation decisions regarding this discussion to the other moderators or administrators.

Mate your Ente Photos app have exact same variable like mine. I have plenty of evidences of you stealing. Stop lying. And don’t tell me how AI works.

At work rn. Let me go home and I will post all the images here of you stealing.

Before making further accusations about Ente Photos, I think it’s important to establish the actual Git history.

Big Bear added Ente Photos on July 7, 2026, through PR #2469, before your ZimaAppStore existed.

Here’s the original pull request, including the Docker Compose configuration and development history:

Additionally, several of the Ente encryption and JWT values originated from Ente’s own official upstream configuration:

I’m happy to examine the evidence you’ve promised to provide, including the exact configuration values and their original commit dates.

However, I think it’s important to establish which implementation existed first and where the allegedly matching values originated before accusing someone of stealing.

I’ll review your evidence when you provide it.

Yeah, yeah, sure. You’re definitely the first one to add these apps. :joy:

Let’s look at the timeline:

  • Affine: You added it 3 weeks ago. I added it last month.
  • AutoXpose: You added it 3 weeks ago. I added it last month.
  • BookOrbit: You added it a month ago. I added it 2 months ago.
  • Cloudreve Pro: You added it 3 weeks ago. I added it last month. And honestly, there’s no way you built this one entirely on your own.
  • Same goes for Cloudreve.
  • Continuwuity: You added it 3 weeks ago. I added it 2 months ago.
  • Documenso, DocuSeal, and plenty of others.

I could keep going, but I have better things to do than waste my time making a list while I’m actually working on my projects.

I get it. You tell your AI to crawl the web and find apps to add to your store. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with using AI. I use it too.

BUT THAT’S NOT THE F POINT.

My point is simple. If you keep taking apps and configurations from other people’s stores, obviously you’ll end up with more apps. So what’s the point of my store or anyone else’s store when you can just copy everything people have already done?

I spend my own time and resources fine-tuning these apps. I test whether the frontend and backend actually work. I even set up a separate test server specifically to test these apps before adding them to my store. I manually troubleshoot issues and make changes to get things working.

And you know what? That takes actual time and effort.

Meanwhile, if your AI is just copying my docker-compose files, what exactly are YOU doing apart from adding “BigBear” everywhere?

Seriously, who the f names an app folder “bigbear-”? :joy:

And the cherry on top? You don’t even give credit to the original developers. No link to their GitHub repositories. Nothing. You’re taking other people’s work and not even doing the bare minimum of acknowledging where it came from.

This is basic f common sense.

And guess what? Someone else has already contacted me about you doing the exact same thing to them. They had 3 apps in their store, and you added all 3 to yours.

So congratulations, mate. I’m clearly not the only person who has noticed this pattern.

Also, your Ente Photos app doesn’t even work properly. The frontend loads, but the backend requires an API that isn’t working in your setup.

Maybe you should steal my latest code as well. At least then you might get it working. :joy:

Compare the git commit dates:

MiniO is now closed source. No longer available so again congrats genius even your Ente app have no storage service.

QUALITY over QUANTITY matters

AI can not do everything lol

Before IceStore and ZimaAppStore, I had already created a repo called CasaOSApps. I added just one app to it, Ente Photos. At that time, I didn’t even know about ZimaOS. I was just testing things, and I didn’t even have a homelab.

I don’t remember the exact date, but it was around May or June 2026. Later, I deleted that repo and started working on ZimaAppStore, followed by IceStore.

My first Ente commit in ZimaAppStore is the one from that store.

So don’t just point to July 7 and act like that settles everything. My work on Ente started before that, even if the current repo came later.

And the same variable values are another reason I’m questioning this. Identical variable values are not something I’m going to ignore, especially when the rest of the pattern is already there.

So again, mate, I’m asking you to explain how this happened instead of hiding behind commit dates.

Just admit it if you copied my work.

Some of these apps, like ZimaBrain, Cloudreve Pro, AutoXpose, openGym, Indelible and others, have barely or very less stars or forks. In short these are less known projects. I know about these projects because I actively follow the subreddit where they were originally posted.

So what are you telling me? That you just happened to find the exact same obscure projects from the exact same subreddit I follow, and then add them to your store too?

And why is it that these exact apps keep appearing in your store shortly after I add them to mine? Is that another coincidence?

Come on, mate. How many coincidences are we supposed to believe here?

I’ve already provided multiple examples, timelines, and matching variable values. I genuinely don’t know how much more evidence I’m supposed to present before you admit.

At this point, I’m asking you to give a straight answer. Explain how you found these projects, why your configurations contain the same variable values as mine, and why you keep adding the same apps shortly after I do.

Hey HSingh, I can understand where you’re coming from, A lot of time and effort goes into developing and testing these apps.

Funny enough, I noticed you’ve got my ZimaBrain in your App Store, and you never asked me for permission either! :joy::joy:

But honestly, mate, I couldn’t care less. I made ZimaBrain publicly available for everyone to use, and if having it in your store helps more people discover it, that’s even better.

I do believe in giving credit where it’s due, especially when someone has put countless hours into a project.

At the end of the day, we’re all part of the same community, and sharing our work is what helps everyone move forward.

Good that you brought this up.

First, ZimaBrain is a single project that you develop and maintain. You provide a basic Docker Compose file, which an average user might not even understand how to configure or deploy. Still, I apologise for not asking your permission first. I should have done that.

I did, however, ask @isanto1306 for permission before adding his DiskMonitor app. The reason I didn’t approach you was that I remember you mentioning somewhere on the forum that people were welcome to use your app. Also, your discussions were quite technical, and I didn’t want to add unnecessary comments to the thread.

I haven’t asked n8n or Cloudreve developers for permission either. I’m building apps for their projects so people can easily deploy them through an OS-specific app store.

But there’s a big difference between maintaining one project and maintaining an entire collection of apps from different developers.

Let me give you an example. How would @Lintux feel if I started adding every single one of his apps to my AppStore? Technically, I could. His work is public, and I could probably make it work. But that doesn’t mean I should ignore the effort he puts into maintaining his own collection.

I’m actually using @Lintux’s Craft Suite because I like his work. That’s exactly why I’ve also added his AppStore to my homelab. I respect what he’s building.

I understand that we’re all part of the same community, and sharing work helps everyone. But there should also be some respect for the time and effort people put into their projects.

Maintaining an AppStore takes considerable time and resources. I even have a dedicated automation system to monitor package updates so I can keep the apps up to date.

I’m not simply collecting Docker Compose files and putting them in a repository. I test, troubleshoot, configure and maintain these apps.

That’s the difference I’m trying to explain.

My logic is pretty simple. For a regular user, there should be a reason to choose my AppStore or @Lintux’s AppStore.

If BigBear keeps adding apps from our stores, what incentive does anyone have to use our stores in the first place?

Why would users bother adding multiple stores when they can just get everything from one place?

I’m not saying you shouldn’t add popular open-source projects. That’s the whole point of community app stores. But if you’re continuously picking up apps that other store maintainers have already discovered, configured, tested and maintained, you’re taking away the very reason those stores exist.

There needs to be some respect for the work that goes into building and maintaining these collections. Otherwise, what’s the point of having multiple independent AppStores?

Actually, mate, you should care about this as well.

There are several reasons why this is a bigger issue:

  1. He is a member of staff.
  2. His AppStore comes pre-installed with fresh ZimaOS installations.
  3. He doesn’t give proper credit to the original developers or sources.
  4. Several of his apps are outdated or simply don’t work.
  5. He has been accused of copying other people’s work. And honestly, at this point, I’ve provided enough evidence to show that this isn’t just an assumption.

And why the hell did he add Trackie? It’s a New Zealand fork. I’m from New Zealand, and I originally added it to my AppStore because I wanted to use it myself. I specifically follow these smaller projects and communities. So how did he end up adding the exact same obscure projects shortly after I did? Another coincidence?

This raises some serious questions about IceWhale itself.

Think about it from an ordinary user’s perspective.

Someone installs ZimaOS for the first time. They open the AppStore and search for Ente Photos. His store is already pre-added, so his version appears in the results. They install it, the frontend loads, but the backend doesn’t work.

What impression does that leave?

Why would that user trust ZimaOS after their first experience with an app that doesn’t even work?

They might simply decide to try another platform, such as Umbrel.

This isn’t just about my AppStore or @Lintux’s AppStore anymore. It’s about the reputation of ZimaOS, the developers who contribute to its ecosystem, and the users who trust the platform.

If IceWhale gives someone this level of visibility through a pre-installed store, surely there should be some responsibility around app quality, proper attribution and respecting other contributors’ work.

I think that’s something worth taking seriously.

Hi everyone, sorry for the delayed response. I’ve just arrived at the office. I’ll review the discussion and gather more background before sharing an official response from IceWhale. Thank you for your patience.

What a loser. :joy: He actually banned me from his Discord.

All I did was send him one message saying, “BigBear is stealing my stuff.” That’s it. No abuse, no long paragraphs, no drama.

He replied, “What are you talking about?” I didn’t even get into an argument with him. I didn’t reply or say anything else. Now I check Discord, and guess what? I’m banned. :joy:

If you haven’t done anything wrong, why not answer the questions and clear things up? Why ban someone for raising concerns instead of addressing them?

Mate, you can’t keep dodging questions and expect people to stop asking them.

The funniest part is that I was ready to discuss the actual evidence. Apparently, even that was too much.

LOL. :joy:

Hey mate, I can understand your frustration, and getting banned from Discord certainly doesn’t help the situation.

But I think we need to separate a few things here. Being banned doesn’t necessarily mean someone has done something wrong or copied your work.

I respect the time and effort you’ve put into your App Store, just as I respect the work BigBear and other developers contribute to the community.

If there’s evidence of copying, the best thing is to put the actual files and GitHub commit dates side by side so everyone can see exactly what’s happened.

Spider has already mentioned that IceWhale is looking into the matter, so let’s give them a chance to review it.

At the end of the day, mate, we’re all here because we enjoy developing, sharing and improving ZimaOS. I’d hate to see good contributors fall out over something that could hopefully be resolved through a proper discussion.

Life’s too short for all this drama! :joy::+1:

Evidence: apps where I was first

First commit date of each app in my store vs the same app in BigBear’s repo

My store BigBear’s My first commit BigBear’s I was ahead by
AFFiNE affine 2026-08-20 2026-10-12 53 days
Cloudreve cloudreve 2026-08-20 2026-10-12 53 days
Continuwuity continuwuity 2026-08-20 2026-10-12 53 days
OmniRoute omniroute 2026-08-20 2026-10-12 53 days
StoatChat stoat 2026-08-20 2026-10-12 53 days
Web-Check web-check 2026-08-20 2026-10-12 53 days
GameVault gamevault 2026-08-22 2026-10-12 51 days
Homelable homelable 2026-08-22 2026-10-12 51 days
Yuvomi yuvomi 2026-09-02 2026-10-12 40 days
openGym opengym 2026-09-02 2026-10-12 40 days
Outline outline 2026-09-04 2026-10-12 38 days
Indelible indelible 2026-09-05 2026-10-12 37 days
ClaudeCode claude-code 2026-09-06 2026-10-12 36 days
DocuSeal docuseal 2026-09-06 2026-10-12 36 days
Documenso documenso 2026-09-06 2026-10-12 36 days
ZimaBrainCE zimabrain 2026-09-06 2026-10-12 36 days
SkySend skysend 2026-09-08 2026-10-12 34 days
Coder coder 2026-09-10 2026-10-12 32 days
AutoXpose autoxpose 2026-09-27 2026-10-12 15 days
Homedex homedex 2026-09-29 2026-10-12 13 days
Trackie trackie 2026-09-29 2026-10-12 13 days
CloudrevePro cloudreve-pro 2026-10-02 2026-10-12 10 days
VSCode vscode 2026-09-10 2026-09-18 8 days
VSCodium vscodium 2026-09-10 2026-09-18 8 days

More

  1. BigBear’s 2026-10-12 date is one PR. Single bulk commit that added 22 of these apps at once. It is #3851, “feat: add 22 Universal Apps from the Zima gap” (commit 385e5ccd). All 22 apps it added are in my store, and none was in BigBear’s repo before it. The PR text also says OmniCloud and SpiderFoot were left out for having no pinned image. Both are in my store. VSCode and VSCodium arrived on 2026-09-18.

  2. Ente. I first built Ente in May/June, in an earlier repo CasaOSApps that I later deleted, so the Ente dates in my current repo start later. App have exact same variable values: “change-me-minio-vH3pL8xC0zN5”

  3. Trackie is a New Zealand-specific fork. I’m from NZ and use it myself, which is why I added it. It’s hard to see why a store not aimed at NZ would list it. How did it come up?

  4. Small projects. Indelible, Homelable, AutoXpose, Homedex, etc are very little-known projects. I found them through the r/selfhosted New Project Megathread, which I read every week. All five were added in PR #3851, 13 to 51 days after I added them (Homedex 13, AutoXpose 15, Indelible 37, OpenGym 40, Homelable 51). How were they found?

  5. Stoat. Both our Stoat apps fail at the API after install. Mine has been that way since I listed it and is on my to-do list.

  6. Discord. I sent one short message, “BigBear is stealing my stuff”, and was banned from his Discord with no explanation.

  7. Still unanswered. How were the 22 apps chosen “from the Zima gap”, from which Zima stores, and why were there no credits or heads-up? @777-Spider, could IceWhale review PR #3851?

Most importantly, WHY IS HE NOT REPLYING HERE? He is online because he banned me from his discord and definitely reading this thread.